Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF)                          H. Kario, Ed. Kario
Request for Comments: 9579                                 Red Hat, Inc.
Updates: 7292, 8018                                             May 2024
Category: Informational
ISSN: 2070-1721

Use of Password-Based Message Authentication Code 1 (PBMAC1) in PKCS #12
                                 Syntax

Abstract

   This document specifies additions and amendments to RFCs 7292 and
   8018.  It defines a way to use the Password-Based Message
   Authentication Code 1 (PBMAC1), defined in RFC 8018, inside the PKCS
   #12 syntax.  The purpose of this specification is to permit the use
   of more modern Password-Based Key Derivation Functions (PBKDFs) and
   allow for regulatory compliance.

Status of This Memo

   This document is not an Internet Standards Track specification; it is
   published for informational purposes.

   This document is a product of the Internet Engineering Task Force
   (IETF).  It represents the consensus of the IETF community.  It has
   received public review and has been approved for publication by the
   Internet Engineering Steering Group (IESG).  Not all documents
   approved by the IESG are candidates for any level of Internet
   Standard; see Section 2 of RFC 7841.

   Information about the current status of this document, any errata,
   and how to provide feedback on it may be obtained at
   https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc9579.

Copyright Notice

   Copyright (c) 2024 IETF Trust and the persons identified as the
   document authors.  All rights reserved.

   This document is subject to BCP 78 and the IETF Trust's Legal
   Provisions Relating to IETF Documents
   (https://trustee.ietf.org/license-info) in effect on the date of
   publication of this document.  Please review these documents
   carefully, as they describe your rights and restrictions with respect
   to this document.  Code Components extracted from this document must
   include Revised BSD License text as described in Section 4.e of the
   Trust Legal Provisions and are provided without warranty as described
   in the Revised BSD License.

Table of Contents

   1.  Introduction
   2.  Rationale
   3.  Requirements Language
   4.  Embedding PBMAC1 in PKCS #12
   5.  Recommended Parameters
   6.  Password Encoding
   7.  Deprecated Algorithms
   8.  IANA Considerations
   9.  Security Considerations
   10. References
     10.1.  Normative References
     10.2.  Informative References
   Appendix A.  Test Vectors
     A.1.  Valid PKCS #12 File with SHA-256 HMAC and PRF
     A.2.  Valid PKCS #12 File with SHA-256 HMAC and SHA-512 PRF
     A.3.  Valid PKCS #12 File with SHA-512 HMAC and PRF
     A.4.  Invalid PKCS #12 File with Incorrect Iteration Count
     A.5.  Invalid PKCS #12 File with Incorrect Salt
     A.6.  Invalid PKCS #12 File with Missing Key Length
   Appendix B.  ASN.1 Module
   Author's Address

1.  Introduction

   The PKCS #12 format [RFC7292] is widely used for the interoperable
   transfer of certificate, key, and other miscellaneous secrets between
   machines, applications, browsers, etc.  Unfortunately, the original
   specification [RFC7292]
   mandates the use of a PKCS #12 specific password-based key derivation function, the PBKDF1,
   function that only allows for change of the underlying message digest
   function.

2.  Rationale

   Due to security concerns with PBKDF1 the key derivation function from
   [RFC7292] and the much higher extensibility of PBMAC1 [RFC8018], we
   propose the use of PBMAC1 for integrity protection of PKCS #12
   structures.  The new syntax is designed to allow legacy applications
   to still be able to decrypt the key material, even if they are unable
   to interpret the new integrity protection, provided that they can
   ignore failures in Message Authentication Code (MAC) verification.
   This change allows for the use of PBKDF2 [RFC8018] or scrypt PBKDFs
   [RFC7914] for derivation of MAC keys and future extensibility.  Use
   of the extensible PBMAC1 mechanism also allows for greater
   flexibility and alignment with different government regulations, for
   example, in environments where PBKDF2 is the only allowed password-based password-
   based key derivation function.

   As the recommended methods for key protection require both encryption
   and integrity protection, we decided to amend the PKCS #12 format to
   support different key derivation functions rather than extending the
   PKCS #5 format by a new field that allows integrity protection.

   We included an ASN.1 module [x680] [x681] [x682] [x683] [x690] that
   can be combined with the ASN.1 module modules in [RFC7292] and [RFC8018] to
   incorporate additional MAC algorithms.

3.  Requirements Language

   The key words "MUST", "MUST NOT", "REQUIRED", "SHALL", "SHALL NOT",
   "SHOULD", "SHOULD NOT", "RECOMMENDED", "NOT RECOMMENDED", "MAY", and
   "OPTIONAL" in this document are to be interpreted as described in
   BCP 14 [RFC2119] [RFC8174] when, and only when, they appear in all
   capitals, as shown here.

4.  Embedding PBMAC1 in PKCS #12

   The MacData structure in the Personal Information Exchange (PFX) PFX object, as described in item #3 in
   Section 4 of [RFC7292], is updated to include the following
   PBMAC1-specific guidance:

   1.

   |  a.  The id-PBMAC1 object identifier is permitted as a valid type
   |      for the DigestAlgorithmIdentifier inside the DigestInfo
   |      object.  If the algorithm field of the
   |      DigestAlgorithmIdentifier is id-
       PBMAC1, id-PBMAC1, then the parameters
   |      field MUST be present and have a value consistent with PBMAC1-params.

   2.
   |      PBMAC1-params parameters.
   |
   |  b.  If the PBMAC1 algorithm is used, the digest value of the
   |      DigestInfo object MUST be the result of the PBMAC1 calculation
   |      over the authSafe field using the PBMAC1-params parameters.

   3.
   |
   |  c.  If the PBMAC1 algorithm is used, the macSalt value MUST be
   |      ignored.  For backwards compatibility, it SHOULD NOT be empty.

   4.
   |
   |  d.  If the PBMAC1 algorithm is used, the iterations value MUST be
   |      ignored.  For backwards compatibility, it SHOULD have a non-zero non-
   |      zero positive value.

5.  Recommended Parameters

   To provide interoperability between different implementations, all
   implementations of this specification MUST support the PBKDF2 key
   derivation function paired with SHA-256 HMAC [SHA2] [RFC2104] for
   both integrity check and as the PBKDF2 pseudorandom function (PRF).
   It's RECOMMENDED for implementations to support other SHA-2-based
   HMACs.  Implementations MAY use other hash functions, like the SHA-3
   family of hash functions [SHA3].  Implementations MAY use other KDF
   methods, like the scrypt PBKDF [RFC7914].

   The length of the key generated by the used KDF MUST be encoded
   explicitly in the parameters field and SHOULD be the same size as the
   HMAC function output size.  This means that PBMAC1-params specifying
   SHA-256 HMAC should also include KDF parameters that generate a
   32-octet key.  In particular, when using the PBKDF2, implementations
   MUST include the keyLen keyLength field in the encoded PBKDF2-params.
   Implementations MUST NOT accept PBKDF2 KDF with PBKDF2-params that
   omit the keyLen keyLength field.

6.  Password Encoding

   As documented in Appendix B.1 of [RFC7292], the handling of password
   encoding in the underlying standards is underspecified.  However,
   just as with PBES1 and PBES2 when used in the context of PKCS #12
   objects, all passwords used with PBMAC1 MUST be created from
   BMPStrings with a NULL terminator.

7.  Deprecated Algorithms

   While attacks against SHA-1 HMACs are not considered practical
   [RFC6194] to limit the number of algorithms needed for
   interoperability, implementations of this specification SHOULD NOT
   use PBKDF2 with the SHA-1 HMAC.  In addition, implementations MUST
   NOT use any other message digest functions with an output of 160 bits
   or less.

8.  IANA Considerations

   IANA has registered the following object identifier in the "SMI
   Security for S/MIME Module Identifier (1.2.840.113549.1.9.16.0)"
   registry.  See Appendix B for the ASN.1 module.

              +=========+=======================+===========+
              | Decimal | Description           | Reference |
              +=========+=======================+===========+
              | 76      | id-pkcs12-pbmac1-2023 | RFC 9579  |
              +---------+-----------------------+-----------+

                                  Table 1

9.  Security Considerations

   Except for the use of different key derivation functions, this
   document doesn't change how the integrity protection on PKCS #12
   objects is computed; therefore, all the security considerations from
   [RFC7292] apply.

   Use of PBMAC1 and PBKDF2 is unchanged from [RFC8018]; therefore, all
   the security considerations from [RFC8018] apply.

   The KDFs generally don't have a lower limit for the generated key
   size, allowing the specification of very small key sizes (of 1
   octet), which can facilitate brute-force attacks on the HMAC.  Since
   the KDF parameters are not cryptographically protected and HMACs
   accept arbitrary key sizes, implementations MAY refuse to process KDF
   parameters that specify small key output sizes or weak parameters.
   It's RECOMMENDED to reject any KDF parameters that specify key
   lengths less than 20 octets.

10.  References

10.1.  Normative References

   [RFC2104]  Krawczyk, H., Bellare, M., and R. Canetti, "HMAC: Keyed-
              Hashing for Message Authentication", RFC 2104,
              DOI 10.17487/RFC2104, February 1997,
              <https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc2104>.

   [RFC2119]  Bradner, S., "Key words for use in RFCs to Indicate
              Requirement Levels", BCP 14, RFC 2119,
              DOI 10.17487/RFC2119, March 1997,
              <https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc2119>.

   [RFC6194]  Polk, T., Chen, L., Turner, S., and P. Hoffman, "Security
              Considerations for the SHA-0 and SHA-1 Message-Digest
              Algorithms", RFC 6194, DOI 10.17487/RFC6194, March 2011,
              <https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc6194>.

   [RFC7292]  Moriarty, K., Ed., Nystrom, M., Parkinson, S., Rusch, A.,
              and M. Scott, "PKCS #12: Personal Information Exchange
              Syntax v1.1", RFC 7292, DOI 10.17487/RFC7292, July 2014,
              <https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc7292>.

   [RFC8018]  Moriarty, K., Ed., Kaliski, B., and A. Rusch, "PKCS #5:
              Password-Based Cryptography Specification Version 2.1",
              RFC 8018, DOI 10.17487/RFC8018, January 2017,
              <https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc8018>.

   [RFC8174]  Leiba, B., "Ambiguity of Uppercase vs Lowercase in RFC
              2119 Key Words", BCP 14, RFC 8174, DOI 10.17487/RFC8174,
              May 2017, <https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc8174>.

   [SHA2]     National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST),
              "Secure Hash Standard (SHS)", FIPS PUB 180-4,
              DOI 10.6028/NIST.FIPS.180-4, August 2015,
              <https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/FIPS/
              NIST.FIPS.180-4.pdf>.

   [x680]     ITU-T, "Information technology - Abstract Syntax Notation
              One (ASN.1): Specification of basic notation", ITU-T
              Recommendation X.680, ISO/IEC 8824-1:2021, February 2021,
              <https://www.itu.int/rec/T-REC-X.680>.

   [x681]     ITU-T, "Information technology - Abstract Syntax Notation
              One (ASN.1): Information object specification", ITU-T
              Recommendation X.681, ISO/IEC 8824-2:2021, February 2021,
              <https://www.itu.int/rec/T-REC-X.681>.

   [x682]     ITU-T, "Information technology - Abstract Syntax Notation
              One (ASN.1): Constraint specification", ITU-T
              Recommendation X.682, ISO/IEC 8824-3:2021, February 2021,
              <https://www.itu.int/rec/T-REC-X.682>.

   [x683]     ITU-T, "Information technology - Abstract Syntax Notation
              One (ASN.1): Parameterization of ASN.1 specifications",
              ITU-T Recommendation X.683, ISO/IEC 8824-4:2021, February
              2021, <https://www.itu.int/rec/T-REC-X.683>.

   [x690]     ITU-T, "Information technology - ASN.1 encoding rules:
              Specification of Basic Encoding Rules (BER), Canonical
              Encoding Rules (CER) and Distinguished Encoding Rules
              (DER)", ITU-T Recommendation X.690, ISO/IEC 8825-1:2021,
              February 2021, <https://www.itu.int/rec/T-REC-X.690>.

10.2.  Informative References

   [RFC7914]  Percival, C. and S. Josefsson, "The scrypt Password-Based
              Key Derivation Function", RFC 7914, DOI 10.17487/RFC7914,
              August 2016, <https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/rfc7914>.

   [SHA3]     National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST),
              "SHA-3 Standard: Permutation-Based Hash and Extendable-
              Output Functions", FIPS PUB 202,
              DOI 10.6028/NIST.FIPS.202, August 2015,
              <https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/FIPS/
              NIST.FIPS.202.pdf>.

Appendix A.  Test Vectors

   All test vectors use "1234" as the password for both encryption and
   integrity protection.

A.1.  Valid PKCS #12 File with SHA-256 HMAC and PRF

   The following base64-encoded PKCS #12 file MUST be readable by
   implementations following this RFC.

   MIIKigIBAzCCCgUGCSqGSIb3DQEHAaCCCfYEggnyMIIJ7jCCBGIGCSqGSIb3DQEH
   BqCCBFMwggRPAgEAMIIESAYJKoZIhvcNAQcBMFcGCSqGSIb3DQEFDTBKMCkGCSqG
   SIb3DQEFDDAcBAg9pxXxY2yscwICCAAwDAYIKoZIhvcNAgkFADAdBglghkgBZQME
   ASoEEK7yYaFQDi1pYwWzm9F/fs+AggPgFIT2XapyaFgDppdvLkdvaF3HXw+zjzKb
   7xFC76DtVPhVTWVHD+kIss+jsj+XyvMwY0aCuAhAG/Dig+vzWomnsqB5ssw5/kTb
   +TMQ5PXLkNeoBmB6ArKeGc/QmCBQvQG/a6b+nXSWmxNpP+71772dmWmB8gcSJ0kF
   Fj75NrIbmNiDMCb71Q8gOzBMFf6BpXf/3xWAJtxyic+tSNETfOJa8zTZb0+lV0w9
   5eUmDrPUpuxEVbb0KJtIc63gRkcfrPtDd6Ii4Zzbzj2Evr4/S4hnrQBsiryVzJWy
   IEjaD0y6+DmG0JwMgRuGi1wBoGowi37GMrDCOyOZWC4n5wHLtYyhR6JaElxbrhxP
   H46z2USLKmZoF+YgEQgYcSBXMgP0t36+XQocFWYi2N5niy02TnctwF430FYsQlhJ
   Suma4I33E808dJuMv8T/soF66HsD4Zj46hOf4nWmas7IaoSAbGKXgIa7KhGRJvij
   xM3WOX0aqNi/8bhnxSA7fCmIy/7opyx5UYJFWGBSmHP1pBHBVmx7Ad8SAsB9MSsh
   nbGjGiUk4h0QcOi29/M9WwFlo4urePyI8PK2qtVAmpD3rTLlsmgzguZ69L0Q/CFU
   fbtqsMF0bgEuh8cfivd1DYFABEt1gypuwCUtCqQ7AXK2nQqOjsQCxVz9i9K8NDeD
   aau98VAl0To2sk3/VR/QUq0PRwU1jPN5BzUevhE7SOy/ImuJKwpGqqFljYdrQmj5
   jDe+LmYH9QGVRlfN8zuU+48FY8CAoeBeHn5AAPml0PYPVUnt3/jQN1+v+CahNVI+
   La8q1Nen+j1R44aa2I3y/pUgtzXRwK+tPrxTQbG030EU51LYJn8amPWmn3w75ZIA
   MJrXWeKj44de7u4zdUsEBVC2uM44rIHM8MFjyYAwYsey0rcp0emsaxzar+7ZA67r
   lDoXvvS3NqsnTXHcn3T9tkPRoee6L7Dh3x4Od96lcRwgdYT5BwyH7e34ld4VTUmJ
   bDEq7Ijvn4JKrwQJh1RCC+Z/ObfkC42xAm7G010u3g08xB0Qujpdg4a7VcuWrywF
   c7hLNquuaF4qoDaVwYXHH3iuX6YlJ/3siTKbYCVXPEZOAMBP9lF/OU76UMJBQNfU
   0xjDx+3AhUVgnGuCsmYlK6ETDp8qOZKGyV0KrNSGtqLx3uMhd7PETeW+ML3tDQ/0
   X9fMkcZHi4C2fXnoHV/qa2dGhBj4jjQ0Xh1poU6mxGn2Mebe2hDsBZkkBpnn7pK4
   wP/VqXdQTwqEuvzGHLVFsCuADe40ZFBmtBrf70wG7ZkO8SUZ8Zz1IX3+S024g7yj
   QRev/6x6TtkwggWEBgkqhkiG9w0BBwGgggV1BIIFcTCCBW0wggVpBgsqhkiG9w0B
   DAoBAqCCBTEwggUtMFcGCSqGSIb3DQEFDTBKMCkGCSqGSIb3DQEFDDAcBAhTxzw+
   VptrYAICCAAwDAYIKoZIhvcNAgkFADAdBglghkgBZQMEASoEEK9nSqc1I2t4tMVG
   bWHpdtQEggTQzCwI7j34gCTvfj6nuOSndAjShGv7mN2j7WMV0pslTpq2b9Bn3vn1
   Y0JMvL4E7sLrUzNU02pdOcfCnEpMFccNv2sQrLp1mOCKxu8OjSqHZLoKVL0ROVsZ
   8dMECLLigDlPKRiSyLErl14tErX4/zbkUaWMROO28kFbTbubQ8YoHlRUwsKW1xLg
   vfi0gRkG/zHXRfQHjX/8NStv7hXlehn7/Gy2EKPsRFhadm/iUHAfmCMkMgHTU248
   JER9+nsXltd59H+IeDpj/kbxZ+YvHow9XUZKu828d3MQnUpLZ1BfJGhMBPVwbVUD
   A40CiQBVdCoGtPJyalL28xoS3H0ILFCnwQOr6u0HwleNJPGHq78HUyH6Hwxnh0b0
   5o163r6wTFZn5cMOxpbs/Ttd+3TrxmrYpd2XnuRme3cnaYJ0ILvpc/8eLLR7SKjD
   T4JhZ0h/CfcV2WWvhpQugkY0pWrZ+EIMneB1dZB96mJVLxOi148OeSgi0PsxZMNi
   YM33rTpwQT5WqOsEyDwUQpne5b8Kkt/s7EN0LJNnPyJJRL1LcqOdr6j+6YqRtPa7
   a9oWJqMcuTP+bqzGRJh+3HDlFBw2Yzp9iadv4KmB2MzhStLUoi2MSjvnnkkd5Led
   sshAd6WbKfF7kLAHQHT4Ai6dMEO4EKkEVF9JBtxCR4JEn6C98Lpg+Lk+rfY7gHOf
   ZxtgGURwgXRY3aLUrdT55ZKgk3ExVKPzi5EhdpAau7JKhpOwyKozAp/OKWMNrz6h
   obu2Mbn1B+IA60psYHHxynBgsJHv7WQmbYh8HyGfHgVvaA8pZCYqxxjpLjSJrR8B
   Bu9H9xkTh7KlhxgreXYv19uAYbUd95kcox9izad6VPnovgFSb+Omdy6PJACPj6hF
   W6PJbucP0YPpO0VtWtQdZZ3df1P0hZ7qvKwOPFA+gKZSckgqASfygiP9V3Zc8jIi
   wjNzoDM2QT+UUJKiiGYXJUEOO9hxzFHlGj759DcNRhpgl5AgR57ofISD9yBuCAJY
   PQ/aZHPFuRTrcVG3RaIbCAS73nEznKyFaLOXfzyfyaSmyhsH253tnyL1MejC+2bR
   Eko/yldgFUxvU5JI+Q3KJ6Awj+PnduHXx71E4UwSuu2xXYMpxnQwI6rroQpZBX82
   HhqgcLV83P8lpzQwPdHjH5zkoxmWdC0+jU/tcQfNXYpJdyoaX7tDmVclLhwl9ps/
   O841pIsNLJWXwvxG6B+3LN/kw4QjwN194PopiOD7+oDm5mhttO78CrBrRxHMD/0Q
   qniZjKzSZepxlZq+J792u8vtMnuzzChxu0Bf3PhIXcJNcVhwUtr0yKe/N+NvC0tm
   p8wyik/BlndxN9eKbdTOi2wIi64h2QG8nOk66wQ/PSIJYwZl6eDNEQSzH/1mGCfU
   QnUT17UC/p+Qgenf6Auap2GWlvsJrB7u/pytz65rtjt/ouo6Ih6EwWqwVVpGXZD0
   7gVWH0Ke/Vr6aPGNvkLcmftPuDZsn9jiig3guhdeyRVf10Ox369kKWcG75q77hxE
   IzSzDyUlBNbnom9SIjut3r+qVYmWONatC6q/4D0I42Lnjd3dEyZx7jmH3g/S2ASM
   FzWr9pvXc61dsYOkdZ4PYa9XPUZxXFagZsoS3F1sU799+IJVU0tC0MExJTAjBgkq
   hkiG9w0BCRUxFgQUwWO5DorvVWYF3BWUmAw0rUEajScwfDBtMEkGCSqGSIb3DQEF
   DjA8MCwGCSqGSIb3DQEFDDAfBAhvRzw4sC4xcwICCAACASAwDAYIKoZIhvcNAgkF
   ADAMBggqhkiG9w0CCQUABCB6pW2FOdcCNj87zS64NUXG36K5aXDnFHctIk5Bf4kG
   3QQITk9UIFVTRUQCAQE=

A.2.  Valid PKCS #12 File with SHA-256 HMAC and SHA-512 PRF

   The following base64-encoded PKCS #12 file SHOULD be readable by
   implementations following this RFC.

   MIIKigIBAzCCCgUGCSqGSIb3DQEHAaCCCfYEggnyMIIJ7jCCBGIGCSqGSIb3DQEH
   BqCCBFMwggRPAgEAMIIESAYJKoZIhvcNAQcBMFcGCSqGSIb3DQEFDTBKMCkGCSqG
   SIb3DQEFDDAcBAi4j6UBBY2iOgICCAAwDAYIKoZIhvcNAgkFADAdBglghkgBZQME
   ASoEEFpHSS5zrk/9pkDo1JRbtE6AggPgtbMLGoFd5KLpVXMdcxLrT129L7/vCr0B
   0I2tnhPPA7aFtRjjuGbwooCMQwxw9qzuCX1eH4xK2LUw6Gbd2H47WimSOWJMaiUb
   wy4alIWELYufe74kXPmKPCyH92lN1hqu8s0EGhIl7nBhWbFzow1+qpIc9/lpujJo
   wodSY+pNBD8oBeoU1m6DgOjgc62apL7m0nwavDUqEt7HAqtTBxKxu/3lpb1q8nbl
   XLTqROax5feXErf+GQAqs24hUJIPg3O1eCMDVzH0h5pgZyRN9ZSIP0HC1i+d1lnb
   JwHyrAhZv8GMdAVKaXHETbq8zTpxT3UE/LmH1gyZGOG2B21D2dvNDKa712sHOS/t
   3XkFngHDLx+a9pVftt6p7Nh6jqI581tb7fyc7HBV9VUc/+xGgPgHZouaZw+I3PUz
   fjHboyLQer22ndBz+l1/S2GhhZ4xLXg4l0ozkgn7DX92S/UlbmcZam1apjGwkGY/
   7ktA8BarNW211mJF+Z+hci+BeDiM7eyEguLCYRdH+/UBiUuYjG1hi5Ki3+42pRZD
   FZkTHGOrcG6qE2KJDsENj+RkGiylG98v7flm4iWFVAB78AlAogT38Bod40evR7Ok
   c48sOIW05eCH/GLSO0MHKcttYUQNMqIDiG1TLzP1czFghhG97AxiTzYkKLx2cYfs
   pgg5PE9drq1fNzBZMUmC2bSwRhGRb5PDu6meD8uqvjxoIIZQAEV53xmD63umlUH1
   jhVXfcWSmhU/+vV/IWStZgQbwhF7DmH2q6S8itCkz7J7Byp5xcDiUOZ5Gpf9RJnk
   DTZoOYM5iA8kte6KCwA+jnmCgstI5EbRbnsNcjNvAT3q/X776VdmnehW0VeL+6k4
   z+GvQkr+D2sxPpldIb5hrb+1rcp9nOQgtpBnbXaT16Lc1HdTNe5kx4ScujXOWwfd
   Iy6bR6H0QFq2SLKAAC0qw4E8h1j3WPxll9e0FXNtoRKdsRuX3jzyqDBrQ6oGskkL
   wnyMtVjSX+3c9xbFc4vyJPFMPwb3Ng3syjUDrOpU5RxaMEAWt4josadWKEeyIC2F
   wrS1dzFn/5wv1g7E7xWq+nLq4zdppsyYOljzNUbhOEtJ2lhme3NJ45fxnxXmrPku
   gBda1lLf29inVuzuTjwtLjQwGk+usHJm9R/K0hTaSNRgepXnjY0cIgS+0gEY1/BW
   k3+Y4GE2JXds2cQToe5rCSYH3QG0QTyUAGvwX6hAlhrRRgUG3vxtYSixQ3UUuwzs
   eQW2SUFLl1611lJ7cQwFSPyr0sL0p81vdxWiigwjkfPtgljZ2QpmzR5rX2xiqItH
   Dy4E+iVigIYwggWEBgkqhkiG9w0BBwGgggV1BIIFcTCCBW0wggVpBgsqhkiG9w0B
   DAoBAqCCBTEwggUtMFcGCSqGSIb3DQEFDTBKMCkGCSqGSIb3DQEFDDAcBAhDiwsh
   4wt3aAICCAAwDAYIKoZIhvcNAgkFADAdBglghkgBZQMEASoEELNFnEpJT65wsXwd
   fZ1g56cEggTQRo04bP/fWfPPZrTEczq1qO1HHV86j76Sgxau2WQ9OQAG998HFtNq
   NxO8R66en6QFhqpWCI73tSJD+oA29qOsT+Xt2bR2z5+K7D4QoiXuLa3gXv62VkjB
   0DLCHAS7Mu+hkp5OKCpXCS7fo0OnAiQjM4EluAsiwwLrHu7z1E16UwpmlgKQnaC1
   S44fV9znS9TxofRTnuCq1lupdn2qQjSydOU6inQeKLBflKRiLrJHOobaFmjWwp1U
   OQAMuZrALhHyIbOFXMPYk3mmU/1UPuRGcbcV5v2Ut2UME+WYExXSCOYR3/R4UfVk
   IfEzeRPFs2slJMIDS2fmMyFkEEElBckhKO9IzhQV3koeKUBdM066ufyax/uIyXPm
   MiB9fAqbQQ4jkQTT80bKkBAP1Bvyg2L8BssstR5iCoZgWnfA9Uz4RI5GbRqbCz7H
   iSkuOIowEqOox3IWbXty5VdWBXNjZBHpbE0CyMLSH/4QdGVw8R0DiCAC0mmaMaZq
   32yrBR32E472N+2KaicvX31MwB/LkZN46c34TGanL5LJZx0DR6ITjdNgP8TlSSrp
   7y2mqi7VbKp/C/28Cj5r+m++Gk6EOUpLHsZ2d2hthrr7xqoPzUAEkkyYWedHJaoQ
   TkoIisZb0MGlXb9thjQ8Ee429ekfjv7CQfSDS6KTE/+mhuJ33mPz1ZcIacHjdHhE
   6rbrKhjSrLbgmrGa8i7ezd89T4EONu0wkG9KW0wM2cn5Gb12PF6rxjTfzypG7a50
   yc1IJ2Wrm0B7gGuYpVoCeIohr7IlxPYdeQGRO/SlzTd0xYaJVm9FzJaMNK0ZqnZo
   QMEPaeq8PC3kMjpa8eAiHXk9K3DWdOWYviGVCPVYIZK6Cpwe+EwfXs+2hZgZlYzc
   vpUWg60md1PD4UsyLQagaj37ubR6K4C4mzlhFx5NovV/C/KD+LgekMbjCtwEQeWy
   agev2l9KUEz73/BT4TgQFM5K2qZpVamwmsOmldPpekGPiUCu5YxYg/y4jUKvAqj1
   S9t4wUAScCJx8OvXUfgpmS2+mhFPBiFps0M4O3nWG91Q6mKMqbNHPUcFDn9P7cUh
   s1xu3NRLyJ+QIfVfba3YBTV8A6WBYEmL9lxf1uL1WS2Bx6+Crh0keyNUPo9cRjpx
   1oj/xkInoc2HQODEkvuK9DD7VrLr7sDhfmJvr1mUfJMQ5/THk7Z+E+NAuMdMtkM2
   yKXxghZAbBrQkU3mIW150i7PsjlUw0o0/LJvQwJIsh6yeJDHY8mby9mIdeP3LQAF
   clYKzNwmgwbdtmVAXmQxLuhmEpXfstIzkBrNJzChzb2onNSfa+r5L6XEHNHl7wCw
   TuuV/JWldNuYXLfVfuv3msfSjSWkv6aRtRWIvmOv0Qba2o05LlwFMd1PzKM5uN4D
   DYtsS9A6yQOXEsvUkWcLOJnCs8SkJRdXhJTxdmzeBqM1JttKwLbgGMbpjbxlg3ns
   N+Z+sEFox+2ZWOglgnBHj0mCZOiAC8wqUu+sxsLT4WndaPWKVqoRQChvDaZaNOaN
   qHciF9HPUcfZow+fH8TnSHneiQcDe6XcMhSaQ2MtpY8/jrgNKguZt22yH9gw/VpT
   3/QOB7FBgKFIEbvUaf3nVjFIlryIheg+LeiBd2isoMNNXaBwcg2YXukxJTAjBgkq
   hkiG9w0BCRUxFgQUwWO5DorvVWYF3BWUmAw0rUEajScwfDBtMEkGCSqGSIb3DQEF
   DjA8MCwGCSqGSIb3DQEFDDAfBAgUr2yP+/DBrgICCAACASAwDAYIKoZIhvcNAgsF
   ADAMBggqhkiG9w0CCQUABCA5zFL93jw8ItGlcbHKhqkNwbgpp6layuOuxSju4/Vd
   6QQITk9UIFVTRUQCAQE=

A.3.  Valid PKCS #12 File with SHA-512 HMAC and PRF

   The following base64-encoded PKCS #12 file SHOULD be readable by
   implementations following this RFC.

   MIIKrAIBAzCCCgUGCSqGSIb3DQEHAaCCCfYEggnyMIIJ7jCCBGIGCSqGSIb3DQEH
   BqCCBFMwggRPAgEAMIIESAYJKoZIhvcNAQcBMFcGCSqGSIb3DQEFDTBKMCkGCSqG
   SIb3DQEFDDAcBAisrqL8obSBaQICCAAwDAYIKoZIhvcNAgkFADAdBglghkgBZQME
   ASoEECjXYYca0pwsgn1Imb9WqFGAggPgT7RcF5YzEJANZU9G3tSdpCHnyWatTlhm
   iCEcBGgwI5gz0+GoX+JCojgYY4g+KxeqznyCu+6GeD00T4Em7SWme9nzAfBFzng0
   3lYCSnahSEKfgHerbzAtq9kgXkclPVk0Liy92/buf0Mqotjjs/5o78AqP86Pwbj8
   xYNuXOU1ivO0JiW2c2HefKYvUvMYlOh99LCoZPLHPkaaZ4scAwDjFeTICU8oowVk
   LKvslrg1pHbfmXHMFJ4yqub37hRtj2CoJNy4+UA2hBYlBi9WnuAJIsjv0qS3kpLe
   4+J2DGe31GNG8pD01XD0l69OlailK1ykh4ap2u0KeD2z357+trCFbpWMMXQcSUCO
   OcVjxYqgv/l1++9huOHoPSt224x4wZfJ7cO2zbAAx/K2CPhdvi4CBaDHADsRq/c8
   SAi+LX5SCocGT51zL5KQD6pnr2ExaVum+U8a3nMPPMv9R2MfFUksYNGgFvS+lcZf
   R3qk/G9iXtSgray0mwRA8pWzoXl43vc9HJuuCU+ryOc/h36NChhQ9ltivUNaiUc2
   b9AAQSrZD8Z7KtxjbH3noS+gjDtimDB0Uh199zaCwQ95y463zdYsNCESm1OT979o
   Y+81BWFMFM/Hog5s7Ynhoi2E9+ZlyLK2UeKwvWjGzvcdPvxHR+5l/h6PyWROlpaZ
   zmzZBm+NKmbXtMD2AEa5+Q32ZqJQhijXZyIji3NS65y81j/a1ZrvU0lOVKA+MSPN
   KU27/eKZuF1LEL6qaazTUmpznLLdaVQy5aZ1qz5dyCziKcuHIclhh+RCblHU6XdE
   6pUTZSRQQiGUIkPUTnU9SFlZc7VwvxgeynLyXPCSzOKNWYGajy1LxDvv28uhMgNd
   WF51bNkl1QYl0fNunGO7YFt4wk+g7CQ/Yu2w4P7S3ZLMw0g4eYclcvyIMt4vxXfp
   VTKIPyzMqLr+0dp1eCPm8fIdaBZUhMUC/OVqLwgnPNY9cXCrn2R1cGKo5LtvtjbH
   2skz/D5DIOErfZSBJ8LE3De4j8MAjOeC8ia8LaM4PNfW/noQP1LBsZtTDTqEy01N
   Z5uliIocyQzlyWChErJv/Wxh+zBpbk1iXc2Owmh2GKjx0VSe7XbiqdoKkONUNUIE
   siseASiU/oXdJYUnBYVEUDJ1HPz7qnKiFhSgxNJZnoPfzbbx1hEzV+wxQqNnWIqQ
   U0s7Jt22wDBzPBHGao2tnGRLuBZWVePJGbsxThGKwrf3vYsNJTxme5KJiaxcPMwE
   r+ln2AqVOzzXHXgIxv/dvK0Qa7pH3AvGzcFjQChTRipgqiRrLor0//8580h+Ly2l
   IFo7bCuztmcwggWEBgkqhkiG9w0BBwGgggV1BIIFcTCCBW0wggVpBgsqhkiG9w0B
   DAoBAqCCBTEwggUtMFcGCSqGSIb3DQEFDTBKMCkGCSqGSIb3DQEFDDAcBAi1c7S5
   IEG77wICCAAwDAYIKoZIhvcNAgkFADAdBglghkgBZQMEASoEEN6rzRtIdYxqOnY+
   aDS3AFYEggTQNdwUoZDXCryOFBUI/z71vfoyAxlnwJLRHNXQUlI7w0KkH22aNnSm
   xiaXHoCP1HgcmsYORS7p/ITi/9atCHqnGR4zHmePNhoMpNHFehdjlUUWgt004vUJ
   5ZwTdXweM+K4We6CfWA/tyvsyGNAsuunel+8243Zsv0mGLKpjA+ZyALt51s0knmX
   OD2DW49FckImUVnNC5LmvEIAmVC/ZNycryZQI+2EBkJKe+BC3834GexJnSwtUBg3
   Xg33ZV7X66kw8tK1Ws5zND5GQAJyIu47mnjZkIWQBY+XbWowrBZ8uXIQuxMZC0p8
   u62oIAtZaVQoVTR1LyR/7PISFW6ApwtbTn6uQxsb16qF8lEM0S1+x0AfJY6Zm11t
   yCqbb2tYZF+X34MoUkR/IYC/KCq/KJdpnd8Yqgfrwjg8dR2WGIxbp2GBHq6BK/DI
   ehOLMcLcsOuP0DEXppfcelMOGNIs+4h4KsjWiHVDMPsqLdozBdm6FLGcno3lY5FO
   +avVrlElAOB+9evgaBbD2lSrEMoOjAoD090tgXXwYBEnWnIpdk+56cf5IpshrLBA
   /+H13LBLes+X1o5dd0Mu+3abp5RtAv7zLPRRtXkDYJPzgNcTvJ2Wxw2C+zrAclzZ
   7IRdcLESUa4CsN01aEvQgOtkCNVjSCtkJGP0FstsWM4hP7lfSB7P2tDL+ugy6GvB
   X1sz9fMC7QMAFL98nDm/yqcnejG1BcQXZho8n0svSfbcVByGlPZGMuI9t25+0B2M
   TAx0f6zoD8+fFmhcVgS6MQPybGKFawckYl0zulsePqs+G4voIW17owGKsRiv06Jm
   ZSwd3KoGmjM49ADzuG9yrQ5PSa0nhVk1tybNape4HNYHrAmmN0ILlN+E0Bs/Edz4
   ntYZuoc/Z35tCgm79dV4/Vl6HUZ1JrLsLrEWCByVytwVFyf3/MwTWdf+Ac+XzBuC
   yEMqPlvnPWswdnaid35pxios79fPl1Hr0/Q6+DoA5GyYq8SFdP7EYLrGMGa5GJ+x
   5nS7z6U4UmZ2sXuKYHnuhB0zi6Y04a+fhT71x02eTeC7aPlEB319UqysujJVJnso
   bkcwOu/Jj0Is9YeFd693dB44xeZuYyvlwoD19lqcim0TSa2Tw7D1W/yu47dKrVP2
   VKxRqomuAQOpoZiuSfq1/7ysrV8U4hIlIU2vnrSVJ8EtPQKsoBW5l70dQGwXyxBk
   BUTHqfJ4LG/kPGRMOtUzgqFw2DjJtbym1q1MZgp2ycMon4vp7DeQLGs2XfEANB+Y
   nRwtjpevqAnIuK6K3Y02LY4FXTNQpC37Xb04bmdIQAcE0MaoP4/hY87aS82PQ68g
   3bI79uKo4we2g+WaEJlEzQ7147ZzV2wbDq89W69x1MWTfaDwlEtd4UaacYchAv7B
   TVaaVFiRAUywWaHGePpZG2WV1feH/zd+temxWR9qMFgBZySg1jipBPVciwl0LqlW
   s/raIBYmLmAaMMgM3759UkNVznDoFHrY4z2EADXp0RHHVzJS1x+yYvp/9I+AcW55
   oN0UP/3uQ6eyz/ix22sovQwhMJ8rmgR6CfyRPKmXu1RPK3puNv7mbFTfTXpYN2vX
   vhEZReXY8hJF/9o4G3UrJ1F0MgUHMCG86cw1z0bhPSaXVoufOnx/fRoxJTAjBgkq
   hkiG9w0BCRUxFgQUwWO5DorvVWYF3BWUmAw0rUEajScwgZ0wgY0wSQYJKoZIhvcN
   AQUOMDwwLAYJKoZIhvcNAQUMMB8ECFDaXOUaOcUPAgIIAAIBQDAMBggqhkiG9w0C
   CwUAMAwGCCqGSIb3DQILBQAEQHIAM8C9OAsHUCj9CmOJioqf7YwD4O/b3UiZ3Wqo
   F6OmQIRDc68SdkZJ6024l4nWlnhTE7a4lb2Tru4k3NOTa1oECE5PVCBVU0VEAgEB

A.4.  Invalid PKCS #12 File with Incorrect Iteration Count

   The following base64-encoded PKCS #12 file MUST NOT be readable by an
   implementation following this RFC when it is verifying integrity
   protection.

   MIIKiwIBAzCCCgUGCSqGSIb3DQEHAaCCCfYEggnyMIIJ7jCCBGIGCSqGSIb3DQEH
   BqCCBFMwggRPAgEAMIIESAYJKoZIhvcNAQcBMFcGCSqGSIb3DQEFDTBKMCkGCSqG
   SIb3DQEFDDAcBAg9pxXxY2yscwICCAAwDAYIKoZIhvcNAgkFADAdBglghkgBZQME
   ASoEEK7yYaFQDi1pYwWzm9F/fs+AggPgFIT2XapyaFgDppdvLkdvaF3HXw+zjzKb
   7xFC76DtVPhVTWVHD+kIss+jsj+XyvMwY0aCuAhAG/Dig+vzWomnsqB5ssw5/kTb
   +TMQ5PXLkNeoBmB6ArKeGc/QmCBQvQG/a6b+nXSWmxNpP+71772dmWmB8gcSJ0kF
   Fj75NrIbmNiDMCb71Q8gOzBMFf6BpXf/3xWAJtxyic+tSNETfOJa8zTZb0+lV0w9
   5eUmDrPUpuxEVbb0KJtIc63gRkcfrPtDd6Ii4Zzbzj2Evr4/S4hnrQBsiryVzJWy
   IEjaD0y6+DmG0JwMgRuGi1wBoGowi37GMrDCOyOZWC4n5wHLtYyhR6JaElxbrhxP
   H46z2USLKmZoF+YgEQgYcSBXMgP0t36+XQocFWYi2N5niy02TnctwF430FYsQlhJ
   Suma4I33E808dJuMv8T/soF66HsD4Zj46hOf4nWmas7IaoSAbGKXgIa7KhGRJvij
   xM3WOX0aqNi/8bhnxSA7fCmIy/7opyx5UYJFWGBSmHP1pBHBVmx7Ad8SAsB9MSsh
   nbGjGiUk4h0QcOi29/M9WwFlo4urePyI8PK2qtVAmpD3rTLlsmgzguZ69L0Q/CFU
   fbtqsMF0bgEuh8cfivd1DYFABEt1gypuwCUtCqQ7AXK2nQqOjsQCxVz9i9K8NDeD
   aau98VAl0To2sk3/VR/QUq0PRwU1jPN5BzUevhE7SOy/ImuJKwpGqqFljYdrQmj5
   jDe+LmYH9QGVRlfN8zuU+48FY8CAoeBeHn5AAPml0PYPVUnt3/jQN1+v+CahNVI+
   La8q1Nen+j1R44aa2I3y/pUgtzXRwK+tPrxTQbG030EU51LYJn8amPWmn3w75ZIA
   MJrXWeKj44de7u4zdUsEBVC2uM44rIHM8MFjyYAwYsey0rcp0emsaxzar+7ZA67r
   lDoXvvS3NqsnTXHcn3T9tkPRoee6L7Dh3x4Od96lcRwgdYT5BwyH7e34ld4VTUmJ
   bDEq7Ijvn4JKrwQJh1RCC+Z/ObfkC42xAm7G010u3g08xB0Qujpdg4a7VcuWrywF
   c7hLNquuaF4qoDaVwYXHH3iuX6YlJ/3siTKbYCVXPEZOAMBP9lF/OU76UMJBQNfU
   0xjDx+3AhUVgnGuCsmYlK6ETDp8qOZKGyV0KrNSGtqLx3uMhd7PETeW+ML3tDQ/0
   X9fMkcZHi4C2fXnoHV/qa2dGhBj4jjQ0Xh1poU6mxGn2Mebe2hDsBZkkBpnn7pK4
   wP/VqXdQTwqEuvzGHLVFsCuADe40ZFBmtBrf70wG7ZkO8SUZ8Zz1IX3+S024g7yj
   QRev/6x6TtkwggWEBgkqhkiG9w0BBwGgggV1BIIFcTCCBW0wggVpBgsqhkiG9w0B
   DAoBAqCCBTEwggUtMFcGCSqGSIb3DQEFDTBKMCkGCSqGSIb3DQEFDDAcBAhTxzw+
   VptrYAICCAAwDAYIKoZIhvcNAgkFADAdBglghkgBZQMEASoEEK9nSqc1I2t4tMVG
   bWHpdtQEggTQzCwI7j34gCTvfj6nuOSndAjShGv7mN2j7WMV0pslTpq2b9Bn3vn1
   Y0JMvL4E7sLrUzNU02pdOcfCnEpMFccNv2sQrLp1mOCKxu8OjSqHZLoKVL0ROVsZ
   8dMECLLigDlPKRiSyLErl14tErX4/zbkUaWMROO28kFbTbubQ8YoHlRUwsKW1xLg
   vfi0gRkG/zHXRfQHjX/8NStv7hXlehn7/Gy2EKPsRFhadm/iUHAfmCMkMgHTU248
   JER9+nsXltd59H+IeDpj/kbxZ+YvHow9XUZKu828d3MQnUpLZ1BfJGhMBPVwbVUD
   A40CiQBVdCoGtPJyalL28xoS3H0ILFCnwQOr6u0HwleNJPGHq78HUyH6Hwxnh0b0
   5o163r6wTFZn5cMOxpbs/Ttd+3TrxmrYpd2XnuRme3cnaYJ0ILvpc/8eLLR7SKjD
   T4JhZ0h/CfcV2WWvhpQugkY0pWrZ+EIMneB1dZB96mJVLxOi148OeSgi0PsxZMNi
   YM33rTpwQT5WqOsEyDwUQpne5b8Kkt/s7EN0LJNnPyJJRL1LcqOdr6j+6YqRtPa7
   a9oWJqMcuTP+bqzGRJh+3HDlFBw2Yzp9iadv4KmB2MzhStLUoi2MSjvnnkkd5Led
   sshAd6WbKfF7kLAHQHT4Ai6dMEO4EKkEVF9JBtxCR4JEn6C98Lpg+Lk+rfY7gHOf
   ZxtgGURwgXRY3aLUrdT55ZKgk3ExVKPzi5EhdpAau7JKhpOwyKozAp/OKWMNrz6h
   obu2Mbn1B+IA60psYHHxynBgsJHv7WQmbYh8HyGfHgVvaA8pZCYqxxjpLjSJrR8B
   Bu9H9xkTh7KlhxgreXYv19uAYbUd95kcox9izad6VPnovgFSb+Omdy6PJACPj6hF
   W6PJbucP0YPpO0VtWtQdZZ3df1P0hZ7qvKwOPFA+gKZSckgqASfygiP9V3Zc8jIi
   wjNzoDM2QT+UUJKiiGYXJUEOO9hxzFHlGj759DcNRhpgl5AgR57ofISD9yBuCAJY
   PQ/aZHPFuRTrcVG3RaIbCAS73nEznKyFaLOXfzyfyaSmyhsH253tnyL1MejC+2bR
   Eko/yldgFUxvU5JI+Q3KJ6Awj+PnduHXx71E4UwSuu2xXYMpxnQwI6rroQpZBX82
   HhqgcLV83P8lpzQwPdHjH5zkoxmWdC0+jU/tcQfNXYpJdyoaX7tDmVclLhwl9ps/
   O841pIsNLJWXwvxG6B+3LN/kw4QjwN194PopiOD7+oDm5mhttO78CrBrRxHMD/0Q
   qniZjKzSZepxlZq+J792u8vtMnuzzChxu0Bf3PhIXcJNcVhwUtr0yKe/N+NvC0tm
   p8wyik/BlndxN9eKbdTOi2wIi64h2QG8nOk66wQ/PSIJYwZl6eDNEQSzH/1mGCfU
   QnUT17UC/p+Qgenf6Auap2GWlvsJrB7u/pytz65rtjt/ouo6Ih6EwWqwVVpGXZD0
   7gVWH0Ke/Vr6aPGNvkLcmftPuDZsn9jiig3guhdeyRVf10Ox369kKWcG75q77hxE
   IzSzDyUlBNbnom9SIjut3r+qVYmWONatC6q/4D0I42Lnjd3dEyZx7jmH3g/S2ASM
   FzWr9pvXc61dsYOkdZ4PYa9XPUZxXFagZsoS3F1sU799+IJVU0tC0MExJTAjBgkq
   hkiG9w0BCRUxFgQUwWO5DorvVWYF3BWUmAw0rUEajScwfTBtMEkGCSqGSIb3DQEF
   DjA8MCwGCSqGSIb3DQEFDDAfBAhvRzw4sC4xcwICCAECASAwDAYIKoZIhvcNAgkF
   ADAMBggqhkiG9w0CCQUABCB6pW2FOdcCNj87zS64NUXG36K5aXDnFHctIk5Bf4kG
   3QQITk9UIFVTRUQCAggA

A.5.  Invalid PKCS #12 File with Incorrect Salt

   The following base64-encoded PKCS #12 file MUST NOT be readable by an
   implementation following this RFC when it is verifying integrity
   protection.

   MIIKigIBAzCCCgUGCSqGSIb3DQEHAaCCCfYEggnyMIIJ7jCCBGIGCSqGSIb3DQEH
   BqCCBFMwggRPAgEAMIIESAYJKoZIhvcNAQcBMFcGCSqGSIb3DQEFDTBKMCkGCSqG
   SIb3DQEFDDAcBAg9pxXxY2yscwICCAAwDAYIKoZIhvcNAgkFADAdBglghkgBZQME
   ASoEEK7yYaFQDi1pYwWzm9F/fs+AggPgFIT2XapyaFgDppdvLkdvaF3HXw+zjzKb
   7xFC76DtVPhVTWVHD+kIss+jsj+XyvMwY0aCuAhAG/Dig+vzWomnsqB5ssw5/kTb
   +TMQ5PXLkNeoBmB6ArKeGc/QmCBQvQG/a6b+nXSWmxNpP+71772dmWmB8gcSJ0kF
   Fj75NrIbmNiDMCb71Q8gOzBMFf6BpXf/3xWAJtxyic+tSNETfOJa8zTZb0+lV0w9
   5eUmDrPUpuxEVbb0KJtIc63gRkcfrPtDd6Ii4Zzbzj2Evr4/S4hnrQBsiryVzJWy
   IEjaD0y6+DmG0JwMgRuGi1wBoGowi37GMrDCOyOZWC4n5wHLtYyhR6JaElxbrhxP
   H46z2USLKmZoF+YgEQgYcSBXMgP0t36+XQocFWYi2N5niy02TnctwF430FYsQlhJ
   Suma4I33E808dJuMv8T/soF66HsD4Zj46hOf4nWmas7IaoSAbGKXgIa7KhGRJvij
   xM3WOX0aqNi/8bhnxSA7fCmIy/7opyx5UYJFWGBSmHP1pBHBVmx7Ad8SAsB9MSsh
   nbGjGiUk4h0QcOi29/M9WwFlo4urePyI8PK2qtVAmpD3rTLlsmgzguZ69L0Q/CFU
   fbtqsMF0bgEuh8cfivd1DYFABEt1gypuwCUtCqQ7AXK2nQqOjsQCxVz9i9K8NDeD
   aau98VAl0To2sk3/VR/QUq0PRwU1jPN5BzUevhE7SOy/ImuJKwpGqqFljYdrQmj5
   jDe+LmYH9QGVRlfN8zuU+48FY8CAoeBeHn5AAPml0PYPVUnt3/jQN1+v+CahNVI+
   La8q1Nen+j1R44aa2I3y/pUgtzXRwK+tPrxTQbG030EU51LYJn8amPWmn3w75ZIA
   MJrXWeKj44de7u4zdUsEBVC2uM44rIHM8MFjyYAwYsey0rcp0emsaxzar+7ZA67r
   lDoXvvS3NqsnTXHcn3T9tkPRoee6L7Dh3x4Od96lcRwgdYT5BwyH7e34ld4VTUmJ
   bDEq7Ijvn4JKrwQJh1RCC+Z/ObfkC42xAm7G010u3g08xB0Qujpdg4a7VcuWrywF
   c7hLNquuaF4qoDaVwYXHH3iuX6YlJ/3siTKbYCVXPEZOAMBP9lF/OU76UMJBQNfU
   0xjDx+3AhUVgnGuCsmYlK6ETDp8qOZKGyV0KrNSGtqLx3uMhd7PETeW+ML3tDQ/0
   X9fMkcZHi4C2fXnoHV/qa2dGhBj4jjQ0Xh1poU6mxGn2Mebe2hDsBZkkBpnn7pK4
   wP/VqXdQTwqEuvzGHLVFsCuADe40ZFBmtBrf70wG7ZkO8SUZ8Zz1IX3+S024g7yj
   QRev/6x6TtkwggWEBgkqhkiG9w0BBwGgggV1BIIFcTCCBW0wggVpBgsqhkiG9w0B
   DAoBAqCCBTEwggUtMFcGCSqGSIb3DQEFDTBKMCkGCSqGSIb3DQEFDDAcBAhTxzw+
   VptrYAICCAAwDAYIKoZIhvcNAgkFADAdBglghkgBZQMEASoEEK9nSqc1I2t4tMVG
   bWHpdtQEggTQzCwI7j34gCTvfj6nuOSndAjShGv7mN2j7WMV0pslTpq2b9Bn3vn1
   Y0JMvL4E7sLrUzNU02pdOcfCnEpMFccNv2sQrLp1mOCKxu8OjSqHZLoKVL0ROVsZ
   8dMECLLigDlPKRiSyLErl14tErX4/zbkUaWMROO28kFbTbubQ8YoHlRUwsKW1xLg
   vfi0gRkG/zHXRfQHjX/8NStv7hXlehn7/Gy2EKPsRFhadm/iUHAfmCMkMgHTU248
   JER9+nsXltd59H+IeDpj/kbxZ+YvHow9XUZKu828d3MQnUpLZ1BfJGhMBPVwbVUD
   A40CiQBVdCoGtPJyalL28xoS3H0ILFCnwQOr6u0HwleNJPGHq78HUyH6Hwxnh0b0
   5o163r6wTFZn5cMOxpbs/Ttd+3TrxmrYpd2XnuRme3cnaYJ0ILvpc/8eLLR7SKjD
   T4JhZ0h/CfcV2WWvhpQugkY0pWrZ+EIMneB1dZB96mJVLxOi148OeSgi0PsxZMNi
   YM33rTpwQT5WqOsEyDwUQpne5b8Kkt/s7EN0LJNnPyJJRL1LcqOdr6j+6YqRtPa7
   a9oWJqMcuTP+bqzGRJh+3HDlFBw2Yzp9iadv4KmB2MzhStLUoi2MSjvnnkkd5Led
   sshAd6WbKfF7kLAHQHT4Ai6dMEO4EKkEVF9JBtxCR4JEn6C98Lpg+Lk+rfY7gHOf
   ZxtgGURwgXRY3aLUrdT55ZKgk3ExVKPzi5EhdpAau7JKhpOwyKozAp/OKWMNrz6h
   obu2Mbn1B+IA60psYHHxynBgsJHv7WQmbYh8HyGfHgVvaA8pZCYqxxjpLjSJrR8B
   Bu9H9xkTh7KlhxgreXYv19uAYbUd95kcox9izad6VPnovgFSb+Omdy6PJACPj6hF
   W6PJbucP0YPpO0VtWtQdZZ3df1P0hZ7qvKwOPFA+gKZSckgqASfygiP9V3Zc8jIi
   wjNzoDM2QT+UUJKiiGYXJUEOO9hxzFHlGj759DcNRhpgl5AgR57ofISD9yBuCAJY
   PQ/aZHPFuRTrcVG3RaIbCAS73nEznKyFaLOXfzyfyaSmyhsH253tnyL1MejC+2bR
   Eko/yldgFUxvU5JI+Q3KJ6Awj+PnduHXx71E4UwSuu2xXYMpxnQwI6rroQpZBX82
   HhqgcLV83P8lpzQwPdHjH5zkoxmWdC0+jU/tcQfNXYpJdyoaX7tDmVclLhwl9ps/
   O841pIsNLJWXwvxG6B+3LN/kw4QjwN194PopiOD7+oDm5mhttO78CrBrRxHMD/0Q
   qniZjKzSZepxlZq+J792u8vtMnuzzChxu0Bf3PhIXcJNcVhwUtr0yKe/N+NvC0tm
   p8wyik/BlndxN9eKbdTOi2wIi64h2QG8nOk66wQ/PSIJYwZl6eDNEQSzH/1mGCfU
   QnUT17UC/p+Qgenf6Auap2GWlvsJrB7u/pytz65rtjt/ouo6Ih6EwWqwVVpGXZD0
   7gVWH0Ke/Vr6aPGNvkLcmftPuDZsn9jiig3guhdeyRVf10Ox369kKWcG75q77hxE
   IzSzDyUlBNbnom9SIjut3r+qVYmWONatC6q/4D0I42Lnjd3dEyZx7jmH3g/S2ASM
   FzWr9pvXc61dsYOkdZ4PYa9XPUZxXFagZsoS3F1sU799+IJVU0tC0MExJTAjBgkq
   hkiG9w0BCRUxFgQUwWO5DorvVWYF3BWUmAw0rUEajScwfDBtMEkGCSqGSIb3DQEF
   DjA8MCwGCSqGSIb3DQEFDDAfBAhOT1QgVVNFRAICCAACASAwDAYIKoZIhvcNAgkF
   ADAMBggqhkiG9w0CCQUABCB6pW2FOdcCNj87zS64NUXG36K5aXDnFHctIk5Bf4kG
   3QQIb0c8OLAuMXMCAQE=

A.6.  Invalid PKCS #12 File with Missing Key Length

   The following base64-encoded PKCS #12 file MUST NOT be readable by an
   implementation following this RFC when it is verifying integrity
   protection.

   MIIKiAIBAzCCCgUGCSqGSIb3DQEHAaCCCfYEggnyMIIJ7jCCBGIGCSqGSIb3DQEH
   BqCCBFMwggRPAgEAMIIESAYJKoZIhvcNAQcBMFcGCSqGSIb3DQEFDTBKMCkGCSqG
   SIb3DQEFDDAcBAg9pxXxY2yscwICCAAwDAYIKoZIhvcNAgkFADAdBglghkgBZQME
   ASoEEK7yYaFQDi1pYwWzm9F/fs+AggPgFIT2XapyaFgDppdvLkdvaF3HXw+zjzKb
   7xFC76DtVPhVTWVHD+kIss+jsj+XyvMwY0aCuAhAG/Dig+vzWomnsqB5ssw5/kTb
   +TMQ5PXLkNeoBmB6ArKeGc/QmCBQvQG/a6b+nXSWmxNpP+71772dmWmB8gcSJ0kF
   Fj75NrIbmNiDMCb71Q8gOzBMFf6BpXf/3xWAJtxyic+tSNETfOJa8zTZb0+lV0w9
   5eUmDrPUpuxEVbb0KJtIc63gRkcfrPtDd6Ii4Zzbzj2Evr4/S4hnrQBsiryVzJWy
   IEjaD0y6+DmG0JwMgRuGi1wBoGowi37GMrDCOyOZWC4n5wHLtYyhR6JaElxbrhxP
   H46z2USLKmZoF+YgEQgYcSBXMgP0t36+XQocFWYi2N5niy02TnctwF430FYsQlhJ
   Suma4I33E808dJuMv8T/soF66HsD4Zj46hOf4nWmas7IaoSAbGKXgIa7KhGRJvij
   xM3WOX0aqNi/8bhnxSA7fCmIy/7opyx5UYJFWGBSmHP1pBHBVmx7Ad8SAsB9MSsh
   nbGjGiUk4h0QcOi29/M9WwFlo4urePyI8PK2qtVAmpD3rTLlsmgzguZ69L0Q/CFU
   fbtqsMF0bgEuh8cfivd1DYFABEt1gypuwCUtCqQ7AXK2nQqOjsQCxVz9i9K8NDeD
   aau98VAl0To2sk3/VR/QUq0PRwU1jPN5BzUevhE7SOy/ImuJKwpGqqFljYdrQmj5
   jDe+LmYH9QGVRlfN8zuU+48FY8CAoeBeHn5AAPml0PYPVUnt3/jQN1+v+CahNVI+
   La8q1Nen+j1R44aa2I3y/pUgtzXRwK+tPrxTQbG030EU51LYJn8amPWmn3w75ZIA
   MJrXWeKj44de7u4zdUsEBVC2uM44rIHM8MFjyYAwYsey0rcp0emsaxzar+7ZA67r
   lDoXvvS3NqsnTXHcn3T9tkPRoee6L7Dh3x4Od96lcRwgdYT5BwyH7e34ld4VTUmJ
   bDEq7Ijvn4JKrwQJh1RCC+Z/ObfkC42xAm7G010u3g08xB0Qujpdg4a7VcuWrywF
   c7hLNquuaF4qoDaVwYXHH3iuX6YlJ/3siTKbYCVXPEZOAMBP9lF/OU76UMJBQNfU
   0xjDx+3AhUVgnGuCsmYlK6ETDp8qOZKGyV0KrNSGtqLx3uMhd7PETeW+ML3tDQ/0
   X9fMkcZHi4C2fXnoHV/qa2dGhBj4jjQ0Xh1poU6mxGn2Mebe2hDsBZkkBpnn7pK4
   wP/VqXdQTwqEuvzGHLVFsCuADe40ZFBmtBrf70wG7ZkO8SUZ8Zz1IX3+S024g7yj
   QRev/6x6TtkwggWEBgkqhkiG9w0BBwGgggV1BIIFcTCCBW0wggVpBgsqhkiG9w0B
   DAoBAqCCBTEwggUtMFcGCSqGSIb3DQEFDTBKMCkGCSqGSIb3DQEFDDAcBAhTxzw+
   VptrYAICCAAwDAYIKoZIhvcNAgkFADAdBglghkgBZQMEASoEEK9nSqc1I2t4tMVG
   bWHpdtQEggTQzCwI7j34gCTvfj6nuOSndAjShGv7mN2j7WMV0pslTpq2b9Bn3vn1
   Y0JMvL4E7sLrUzNU02pdOcfCnEpMFccNv2sQrLp1mOCKxu8OjSqHZLoKVL0ROVsZ
   8dMECLLigDlPKRiSyLErl14tErX4/zbkUaWMROO28kFbTbubQ8YoHlRUwsKW1xLg
   vfi0gRkG/zHXRfQHjX/8NStv7hXlehn7/Gy2EKPsRFhadm/iUHAfmCMkMgHTU248
   JER9+nsXltd59H+IeDpj/kbxZ+YvHow9XUZKu828d3MQnUpLZ1BfJGhMBPVwbVUD
   A40CiQBVdCoGtPJyalL28xoS3H0ILFCnwQOr6u0HwleNJPGHq78HUyH6Hwxnh0b0
   5o163r6wTFZn5cMOxpbs/Ttd+3TrxmrYpd2XnuRme3cnaYJ0ILvpc/8eLLR7SKjD
   T4JhZ0h/CfcV2WWvhpQugkY0pWrZ+EIMneB1dZB96mJVLxOi148OeSgi0PsxZMNi
   YM33rTpwQT5WqOsEyDwUQpne5b8Kkt/s7EN0LJNnPyJJRL1LcqOdr6j+6YqRtPa7
   a9oWJqMcuTP+bqzGRJh+3HDlFBw2Yzp9iadv4KmB2MzhStLUoi2MSjvnnkkd5Led
   sshAd6WbKfF7kLAHQHT4Ai6dMEO4EKkEVF9JBtxCR4JEn6C98Lpg+Lk+rfY7gHOf
   ZxtgGURwgXRY3aLUrdT55ZKgk3ExVKPzi5EhdpAau7JKhpOwyKozAp/OKWMNrz6h
   obu2Mbn1B+IA60psYHHxynBgsJHv7WQmbYh8HyGfHgVvaA8pZCYqxxjpLjSJrR8B
   Bu9H9xkTh7KlhxgreXYv19uAYbUd95kcox9izad6VPnovgFSb+Omdy6PJACPj6hF
   W6PJbucP0YPpO0VtWtQdZZ3df1P0hZ7qvKwOPFA+gKZSckgqASfygiP9V3Zc8jIi
   wjNzoDM2QT+UUJKiiGYXJUEOO9hxzFHlGj759DcNRhpgl5AgR57ofISD9yBuCAJY
   PQ/aZHPFuRTrcVG3RaIbCAS73nEznKyFaLOXfzyfyaSmyhsH253tnyL1MejC+2bR
   Eko/yldgFUxvU5JI+Q3KJ6Awj+PnduHXx71E4UwSuu2xXYMpxnQwI6rroQpZBX82
   HhqgcLV83P8lpzQwPdHjH5zkoxmWdC0+jU/tcQfNXYpJdyoaX7tDmVclLhwl9ps/
   O841pIsNLJWXwvxG6B+3LN/kw4QjwN194PopiOD7+oDm5mhttO78CrBrRxHMD/0Q
   qniZjKzSZepxlZq+J792u8vtMnuzzChxu0Bf3PhIXcJNcVhwUtr0yKe/N+NvC0tm
   p8wyik/BlndxN9eKbdTOi2wIi64h2QG8nOk66wQ/PSIJYwZl6eDNEQSzH/1mGCfU
   QnUT17UC/p+Qgenf6Auap2GWlvsJrB7u/pytz65rtjt/ouo6Ih6EwWqwVVpGXZD0
   7gVWH0Ke/Vr6aPGNvkLcmftPuDZsn9jiig3guhdeyRVf10Ox369kKWcG75q77hxE
   IzSzDyUlBNbnom9SIjut3r+qVYmWONatC6q/4D0I42Lnjd3dEyZx7jmH3g/S2ASM
   FzWr9pvXc61dsYOkdZ4PYa9XPUZxXFagZsoS3F1sU799+IJVU0tC0MExJTAjBgkq
   hkiG9w0BCRUxFgQUwWO5DorvVWYF3BWUmAw0rUEajScwejBqMEYGCSqGSIb3DQEF
   DjA5MCkGCSqGSIb3DQEFDDAcBAhvRzw4sC4xcwICCAAwDAYIKoZIhvcNAgkFADAM
   BggqhkiG9w0CCQUABCB6pW2FOdcCNj87zS64NUXG36K5aXDnFHctIk5Bf4kG3QQI
   b0c8OLAuMXMCAggA

Appendix B.  ASN.1 Module

   This appendix documents ASN.1 [x680] [x681] [x682] [x683] [x690]
   types, values, and object sets for this specification.  It does so by
   providing an ASN.1 module called PKCS12-PBMAC1-2023.

   Combine this module with the PKCS-12 ASN.1 module found in Appendix D
   of [RFC7292] and the pkcs5v2-1 ASN.1 module in Appendix C of
   [RFC8018] to add SHA-2-based HMACs by replacing the PBKDF2-PRFs class found therein.
   referenced from [RFC7292].

   PKCS12-PBMAC1-2023
     { iso(1) member-body(2) us(840) rsadsi(113549) pkcs(1) pkcs9(9)
       smime(16) id-mod(0) id-pkcs12-pbmac1-2023(76) }

   DEFINITIONS EXPLICIT TAGS ::=
   BEGIN

   IMPORTS

   AlgorithmIdentifier, ALGORITHM-IDENTIFIER, rsadsi
     FROM PKCS5v2-1 -- From [RFC8018]
      { iso(1) member-body(2) us(840) rsadsi(113549) pkcs(1) pkcs-5(5)
        modules(16) pkcs5v2-1(2) }
   ;

   -- object identifier arcs

   pkcs OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rsadsi 1 }

   pkcs-5 OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { pkcs 5 }

   digestAlgorithm OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { rsadsi 2 }

   -- HMAC object identifiers

   id-hmacWithSHA1 OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { digestAlgorithm 7 }

   id-hmacWithSHA224 OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { digestAlgorithm 8 }

   id-hmacWithSHA256 OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { digestAlgorithm 9 }

   id-hmacWithSHA384 OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { digestAlgorithm 10 }

   id-hmacWithSHA512 OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { digestAlgorithm 11 }

   id-hmacWithSHA512-224 OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { digestAlgorithm 12 }

   id-hmacWithSHA512-256 OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { digestAlgorithm 13 }

   -- PBKDF2-PRF algorithm identifiers

   PBKDF2-PRFs ALGORITHM-IDENTIFIER ::= {
     { NULL IDENTIFIED BY id-hmacWithSHA1 }       |
     { NULL IDENTIFIED BY id-hmacWithSHA224 }     |
     { NULL IDENTIFIED BY id-hmacWithSHA256 }     |
     { NULL IDENTIFIED BY id-hmacWithSHA384 }     |
     { NULL IDENTIFIED BY id-hmacWithSHA512 }     |
     { NULL IDENTIFIED BY id-hmacWithSHA512-224 } |
     { NULL IDENTIFIED BY id-hmacWithSHA512-256 },
     ...
     }

   -- HMAC algorithm identifiers

   algid-hmacWithSHA1 AlgorithmIdentifier {{PBKDF2-PRFs}} ::=
     { algorithm id-hmacWithSHA1, parameters NULL : NULL }

   algid-hmacWithSHA224 AlgorithmIdentifier {{PBKDF2-PRFs}} ::=
     { algorithm id-hmacWithSHA224, parameters NULL : NULL }

   algid-hmacWithSHA256 AlgorithmIdentifier {{PBKDF2-PRFs}} ::=
     { algorithm id-hmacWithSHA256, parameters NULL : NULL }

   algid-hmacWithSHA384 AlgorithmIdentifier {{PBKDF2-PRFs}} ::=
     { algorithm id-hmacWithSHA384, parameters NULL : NULL }

   algid-hmacWithSHA512 AlgorithmIdentifier {{PBKDF2-PRFs}} ::=
     { algorithm id-hmacWithSHA512, parameters NULL : NULL }

   algid-hmacWithSHA512-224 AlgorithmIdentifier {{PBKDF2-PRFs}} ::=
     { algorithm id-hmacWithSHA512-224, parameters NULL : NULL }

   algid-hmacWithSHA512-256 AlgorithmIdentifier {{PBKDF2-PRFs}} ::=
     { algorithm id-hmacWithSHA512-256, parameters NULL : NULL }

   -- PBMAC1-params

   PBMAC1-params ::=  SEQUENCE {
     keyDerivationFunc AlgorithmIdentifier {{PBMAC1-KDFs}},
     messageAuthScheme AlgorithmIdentifier {{PBMAC1-MACs}} }

   PBMAC1-KDFs ALGORITHM-IDENTIFIER ::= {
     { PBKDF2-params IDENTIFIED BY id-PBKDF2},
     ...
   }

   PBMAC1-MACs ALGORITHM-IDENTIFIER ::= { ... }

   id-PBKDF2 OBJECT IDENTIFIER ::= { pkcs-5 12 }

   PBKDF2-params ::= SEQUENCE {
     salt CHOICE {
       specified OCTET STRING,
       otherSource AlgorithmIdentifier {{PBKDF2-SaltSources}}
     },
     iterationCount INTEGER (1..MAX),
     keyLength INTEGER (1..MAX) OPTIONAL,
     prf AlgorithmIdentifier {{PBKDF2-PRFs}} DEFAULT algid-hmacWithSHA1
   }

   PBKDF2-SaltSources ALGORITHM-IDENTIFIER ::= { ... }

   END

Author's Address

   Hubert Kario (editor)
   Red Hat, Inc.
   Purkynova 115
   61200 Brno
   Czech Republic
   Email: hkario@redhat.com